Sorokin-Brinton exchange

 

Posted here are Russian translations of:

Crane Brinton. “Socio-Astrology” (The Southern Review 3.2, Fall 1937)

and

Sorokin’s rejoinder, “Histrionics” (The Southern Review 3.3, Winter 1938).

Brinton’s article was a review-essay of the first three volumes of Sorokin’s Social and Cultural Dynamics (The American Book Company, 1937).

Clarence Crane Brinton (1898-1968) was an American historian. He was the McLean Professor of Ancient and Modern History at his alma mater, Harvard University.

The translations, published in Naslsedie  No. 1 (26) (2025). are by Natalia S. Sergieva and Roger W. Smith.

– posted by Roger W. Smith

     September 2025

 

Brinton-Sorokin (trans Sergieva, Smith)

Crane Brinton, ‘Socio-Astrology’

‘Historionics’ (Sorokin reply to Crane Brinton)

nasledie_26-1

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Reginaldo Nunes, “Russia e EE. UU.” (Russia and the United States)

 

 

MG449_Sorokin_Box5_A-14_Nunes

 

Posted here (PDF above; Word documents below):

Reginaldo Nunes, “Russia e EE. UU.” (Russia and the United States)

published in the newspaper Rio de Janeiro, May 31, 1945 (a review of Sorokin’s Russia and the United States)

 

Nunes PORTUGUESE

Nunes ENGLISH

 

— posted by Roger W. Smith

     May 2025

a critical review of Sorokin’s “Sociological Theories of Today”

 

review of Sociological Theories of Today – Sociological Bulletin, March 1967

 

posted here (PDF above)

review of Sociological Theories of Today

By Pitirim A. Sorokin

reviewed by D. Narain

Sociological Bulletin

Volume 16, Number 1 (March 1967)

pp. 95-100

 

— posted by Roger W. Smith

      April 2024

a critical review of Sorokin’s “Fads and Foibles”

 

Jean Floud review of ‘Fads and Foibles in Modern Sociology’

 

posted here (PDF above)

review of Fads and Foibles in Modern Sociology and Related Sciences

By Pitirim A. Sorokin

reviewed by Jean Floud

British Journal of Educational Studies

Volume VI, Number 1 (November 1957)

pp. 84-86

Jean Esther Floud (1915-2013) was a prominent sociologist. She was the Principal of Newnham College, Cambridge, from 1972 to 1983.

 

— posted by Roger W. Smith

      April 2024

“A Sociologist’s Political Memories”

 

review of Leaves from a Russian Diary – Chicago Evening Post 1-30-1925

 

Posted here:

“A Sociologist’s Political Memories”

review of Sorokin, Leaves from a Russian Diary

reviewed by Lawrence Martin

The Chicago Evening Post Literary Review

January 30, 1925

 

*****************************************************

a “footnote”

I read Sorokin’s Leaves years ago, after “discovering” him. It was the second Sorokin book I read (after The Crisis of Our Age). It was unforgettable; it made a very strong impression of me.

This review conveys the excitement that the book conveyed. And it hints at some of its weaknesses, which I would say are those of a lot of good storytellers: a tendency at times to exaggeration and of, at times, “polishing the apple,” which is to say “prettying” incidents for effect.

 

— posted by Roger W. Smith

     February 2024

Adolfo Posada, “Ética y sociología de la revolución”; “Sociología y ética de la revolución”; La Nación, 1925 (re Sorokin’s The Sociology of Revolution)

 

Nov 1 1925

Dec 6, 1925

Posada,’La Lamma Intima’

 

Posted here (PDFs above)

Adolfo Posada

Ética y sociología de la revolución

La Nación

November 1, 1925

 

Adolfo Posada

Sociología y ética de la revolución

La Nación

December 6, 1925

 

*****************************************************

I have transcribed and translated both articles, which are posted here:

 

the original Spanish

November 1 SPANISH

December 6 SPANISH

 

English translations by Roger W. Smith

November 1 ENGLISH

December 6 ENGLISH

 

*****************************************************

Adolfo González-Posada y Biesca (1860-1944) was a Spanish jurist, sociologist, translator, writer and politician linked to regenerationism. He was Professor of Political Law the Universidá Complutense de Madrid

Regenerationism was an intellectual and political movement in late nineteenth and early twentieth century Spain. It sought to make objective and scientific study of the causes of Spain’s decline as a nation and to propose remedies. It is largely seen as distinct from another movement of the same time and place, the Generation of ’98. While both movements shared a similar negative judgment of the course of Spain as a nation in recent times, the regenerationists sought to be objective, documentary, and scientific, while the Generation of ’98 inclined more to the literary, subjective and artistic. (Wikipedia)

La Nación was a Spanish newspaper published in Madrid between 1925 and 1936. During the dictatorship of Primo de Rivera, the newspaper was the central organ of the Patriotic Union and also served as the “official” newspaper of the regime. (Wikipedia)

*****************************************************

Acknowledgment:

I wish to thank Lindsay A. Stokalko, Archives Specialist, University Archives and Special Collections, University of Saskatchewan, for procuring this article from the Sorokin archives, and for overseeing photocopying of the document, which presented difficulties. Some Spanish archive presumably has copies of La Nación, but I was unable to find or obtain them anywhere else; and I doubt that Sorokin scholars have seen these articles before.

 

— posted by Roger W. Smith

     September 2023

“One Disillusionment More”

 

Sorokin review of ‘The Bolshevist Myth’ and another book – Saturday Review 10-24-1925 pp 237-238

 

Posted here:

Sorokin’s review of

The Bolshevist Myth, by Alexander Berkman

The Speckled Domes, by Gerhard Shelley

The Saturday Review, October 24, 1925, pp. 237-238

 

— Roger W. Smith

     January 2023

a review of “Hunger as a Factor”

 

C. Peter Timmer review of Hunger as a Factor – American J of Sociology

 

Posted here (PDF above):

review of Pitirim A Sorokin, Hunger as a Factor in Human Affairs; translated by Elena P. Sorokin

reviewed by C. Peter Timmer

American Journal of Sociology, Vol. 82, No. 4 (January 1977), pp. 912-914

I disagree with the conclusions drawn by Timmer at the end of the review with respect to Sorokin’s conclusions (reached by Sorokin in the book’s concluding pages) about the relationship between hunger and statism.

 

posted by Roger W. Smith

     October 2022

review, The Sociology of Revolution (North American Review)

 

Clarence H. Gaines review of The Sociology of Revolution & other works – North American Review (2)

posted here (PDF file above):

Clarence H. Gaines, review of Sorokin’s The Sociology of Revolution and other works

The North American Review

June 1, 1925

 

*****************************************************

Editorial comment:  This review, in my opinion, does an excellent job of delineating why Sorokin’s study is so original and fresh, even today. And valuable.

 

posted by Roger W. Smith

     July 2022

“A Disillusioned Intellectual”

 

review of Leaves from a Russian Diary – Workers Monthly 1-1-1925 pg 113

 

Posted here (PDF file above)

review of Sorokin’s Leaves from a Russian Diary

reviewed by Alexander Bittelman

Workers Monthly

January 1, 1925

 

*****************************************************

Alexander Bittelman (1890–1982) was a Russian-born American communist political activist, Marxist theorist, influential theoretician of the Communist Party USA, and writer. A founding member, Bittelman is best remembered as the chief factional lieutenant of William Z. Foster and as a longtime editor of The Communist, its monthly magazine. (Wikipedia)

 

— posted by Roger W. Smith

     July 2022